Chrysanthemums, ancient swords, and wine
Are steeped in the bustling courtyard by coffee
Foreigners worship the ancient moon at the Sun Altar
The prosperous era of Kaiyuan is enchanting and nostalgic
Following the lines of my palm, fate is imprinted
Tonight, I awaken from wine without dreams
Walking along the path of fate into confusion
In my dreams, I return to the Tang Dynasty.
Chronology: Late Tang
Year
Event
Description
618
Founding of Tang dynasty
New centralized aristocratic empire, with non-Chinese people integrated.
755-763
An Lushan rebellion
Frontier military rebellion, wrecking havoc on the dynasty.
760-907
Late Tang
Devolution of imperial power to frontier kingdoms; retreat of gov from commerce.
874-884
Huang Chao rebellion
A salt merchant who failed the civil service exam launched a bandit revolt.
907-960
Five Dynasties
China in fragmentation until the founding of Song Dynasty.
Two Master Narratives about Late Tang
From prosperity to decline
Loss of self-confidence and governmental effectiveness after “barbarian attack”
Internal decay and ultimate collapse
From cosmopolitanism to xenophobia
Growing rejection of Buddhism
Withdrawal from Central Asia and anti-foreign isolation
Key Questions
Late Tang in the World: Shifting Frontiers of Empire, From Central Asia to Sinosphere
Reforming Tang: How to re-centralize authority after An Lushan’s Rebellion?
What do we we remember when we remember the Tang Dynasty?
Tang China and Its Neighbors
Tibet as a World Power
The rising power of Tibet, which nominally aligned with the Tang in the 630s, expanded north and west.
The An Lushan rebellion marked a turning point, reversing the balance of power between the Tang and Tibet.
After Emperor Xuanzong temporarily fled to Sichuan, the Uighurs helped rescue the Tang but later withdrew their support due to unmet expectations.
In 763, Tibetans occupied parts of modern Qinghai and Gansu, invaded Shaanxi, and pillaged Chang’an.
The Tang, under Guo Ziyi, managed to recapture the capital but faced a combined Uighur and Tibetan army that took it again in 765.
Tang and Nanzhao: From Foe to Friend
The region that would become Yunnan province gradually formed into a unified state known as Nanzhao, which emerged in the mid-seventh century.
Nanzhao strategically played Tang China against Tibet, leading both powers to believe they were allies at different times.
It initially supported Tibet in the mid-eighth century but later reversed its position to ally with Tang China as the century ended.
Tang and Uyghur Empire
The Tang dynasty made significant financial outlays, sending 900,000 bolts of silk annually to military headquarters in the Western Regions.
These expenditures abruptly ceased with the An Lushan rebellion, which led to cessation of military payments and the hiring of Uighur mercenaries to combat the An Lushan rebels.
Uyghur is not Uyghur
Uyghur Empire ≠ Xinjiang Autonomous Region
Uyghur ≠ Ethnicity/Nationality in Contemporary China
Manichaeism: Official Religion of the Uyghur Kaghanate
In 763, the Tang dynasty managed to suppress the rebellion, but during this period, Uighur mercenaries occupied Luoyang and encountered a Sogdian teacher who introduced them to Manichaeism.
The Uighur kaghan adopted Manichaeism as the official religion, marking the first instance in history of a state officially endorsing this faith.
After the kaghan’s conversion, Manichaeism became the official religion of the Uighur Kaghanate.
What is Manichaeism?
Manichaeism is a dualistic religious movement founded in the 3rd century CE by Mani, the “Apostle of Light.”
He viewed himself as the final prophet in a lineage that included Adam, Buddha, Zoroaster, and Jesus.
There are two opposing forces in the world: good (light) and evil (darkness). Mani believed that his teachings offered a universal truth that could bring together ideas from different religions.
Initially viewed as a Christian heresy, it was a distinct religion with coherent doctrines and a structured organization.
Discuss: Tale of the Horseman
Fragment from a Manichaean text depicting a “Sermon Scene” in the Uyghur-Manichaean style, Uyghur Manichaean “Sermon Scene”, shown from picture-viewing direction. Leaf from a Manichaean book (MIK III 8259 folio 1 recto), detail with intracolumnar book painting. Museum für Indische Kunst, Berlin.
Tang and Uyghur: Uneasy Allies
A split among the Uighurs allowed the Tang to ally with them and regain control.
For over fifty years, the Tang relied on Uighur support against Tibetan incursions, leading to Uighur disregard for imperial authority in the late eighth and early ninth centuries.
An internal split in Uighur leadership allowed the Kirghiz to attack, prompting the Tang to ally with them against the Uighurs.
Despite fluctuating alliances with the Uighurs, the Tang dynasty could not reassert its authority in Central Asia, as Tibet continued to control much of modern Qinghai and Gansu and destroyed the western protectorate-general.
Rise of Islam
After defeating the Sasanian Empire in 651, the Arabs targeted Central Asia, capturing Samarkand for the first time in 671.
Within a few decades, Muslim forces secured the region, leading to the displacement of the Sogdian language by Persian and the replacement of Zoroastrianism with Islam.
After the mid-8th century, Samarkand and Sogdiana shifted their focus away from China.
Tang and the Loss of Central Asia
After the collapse of the Tibetan kingdom by 850 and the decline of Nanzhao in the late ninth century, the Tang empire did not regain its influence in Central Asia, which came under the control of expanding Arab powers spreading Islam.
The An Lushan rebellion and Tibetan conquests in northwest China allowed Arabs to advance into Central Asia, resulting in the loss of Chinese control west of Dunhuang until the Manchu conquest in the 18th century.
This shift led to the permanent loss of Central Asia as a part of the Buddhist world and removed it from the Chinese cultural sphere.
End of the Silk Road
Central Asia as a cross-road of empire, influenced by Indo-European, Iranian, Indian, and Chinese elements.
This led to the region becoming a frontier zone of the Islamic world, shifting away from Chinese cultural and political influence.
The decline of Buddhism in Central Asia and India, coupled with its suppression in China during the 840s, resulted in Chinese Buddhism losing its Indian inspiration and evolving into a distinctly Chinese religion influenced by local intellectual traditions like Chan and Pure Land.
China as Center of Buddhism
The Tang dynasty’s focus shifted from Central Asia to the east, altering China’s relations with Buddhism and its trade connections.
As Chinese influence waned in Central Asia and ties with India were severed, Chinese culture and Mahayana Buddhism expanded more deeply into East Asia.
Tibet remained more aligned with Central Asia, turning to India for Tantric Buddhism, which represented the last significant flourish of Indian Buddhism during the Pala period in Bengal (circa 750–1155).
China as Model in East Asia
The states connected to Tang China primarily emulated its political and legal institutions, but they also shared a common adherence to Buddhism and a non-alphabetic script.
Political system
Centralized monarchy
Tang Laws
Buddhism
Shared Mahayana Buddhist faith across the East Asian cultural sphere.
Chinese writing
Use of Chinese characters.
Diverse linguistic groups able read and understand the same texts despite differing pronunciations.
Shared culture
Beliefs in ritual behavior, the centrality of family, hierarchy, gender separation, and text-based learning.
Tang and Japan
Monk Ennin
In 630, Japan sent its first delegation to the Tang dynasty, despite geographic distance.
In 649, Japan initiated major political reforms to establish a centralized monarchy.
The Japanese government adopted the Chinese writing system for official and literary purposes, adapting it for the Japanese language.
Chinese elite cultural elements influenced Japan, including clothing, poetry, and music at the Heian court.
Buddhism became a significant intellectual and religious force in Japan, leading to many Japanese pilgrims traveling to Tang China.
From Kanji to Kana
Sui and Tang: The Korean Question
At the start of the Tang dynasty, the Korean peninsula was divided into three kingdoms: Koguryô, Silla, and Paekche.
The Sui dynasty fell partly due to costly campaigns against Koguryô, but all three Korean states sent tribute to the Tang court upon its establishment.
In 622, Tang Gaozu recognized the independence of the Korean states as nominal vassals after returning Chinese prisoners.
In 640, princes from the Korean states, Gaochang, Japan, and Tibet studied at the Tang imperial academy in Chang’an.
Conquests that Failed
A Koguryô minister’s coup in 642 led to instability, prompting Tang Taizong to launch unsuccessful military campaigns against Koguryô in 645, 647, and 648.
Under Emperor Gaozong, the Tang allied with Silla, which adopted Chinese writing and governance, to invade and occupy Paekche, then launched an expedition against Koguryô.
After the death of Koguryô’s ruler in 666, the Tang occupied the state and took over 200,000 prisoners to Chang’an in 668.
Tang and Silla
By the 670s, Silla, now influenced by Chinese culture, managed to unify most of Korea, while the Tang shifted focus to the threat from Tibet, abandoning further conquests in Korea.
Korea remained a nominal vassal of the Tang, structured similarly to the Chinese state.
The Emergence of East Asia
Tang China’s foreign relations were influenced by the rise of sedentary states to the east, south, and southwest that embraced Chinese civilization, notably Korea, Japan, and Nanzhao (in Yunnan).
Surrounding states often established themselves through a process of investiture, where local chieftains sent gifts to the Chinese court in exchange for titles (such as kings or dukes) and official seals of office.
Tang as Maritime Power
In the ninth century, two major powers dominated Asia: the Tang dynasty in China and the Abbasid Caliphate in West Asia, with its capital in Baghdad.
The Southeast Asian kingdom of Srivijaya controlled key sea routes through Sumatra, Java, and the Malay Peninsula, serving as a crucial link between East and West.
These regions were interconnected through overland and maritime trade.
From Land to Sea
Maritime transport allowed for the bulk export of fragile yet heavy goods, such as ceramics.
The popularity of maritime routes increased during the Tang dynasty due to dangers associated with overland travel, such as the Arab conquest and civil war in China, leading to a decline in overland trade by the eighth century.
Belitung shipwreck
In 1998, fishermen near Belitung Island discovered a mound on the sea floor.
The vessel was made from wood sourced from Africa, the Indian Subcontinent, and Arabia, using an ancient shipbuilding technique still practiced in Oman.
This find marked the first excavation of an ancient Middle-Eastern shipwreck.
Reforming Tang
Broadly speaking
How should Tang manage its relationship with its neighbors?
How should Tang reform its internal politics?
Liu Zongyuan
What is the ideal political structure for administering the empire, according to Liu Zongyuan?
Who should be in charge of administration, and why?
Debate about Statecraft
What should be the basic structure for administering the empire?
Enfeoffment system (fengjian)
The emperor gave power to his close relatives or high officials to govern the provinces, sometimes on a hereditary basis.
Prefecture and county system (junxian)
Centralized appointment of local prefects and magistrate
Officials hold office usually for not more than four years in a locality and could not serve in their own home districts (law of avoidance)
Debate: Fengjian vs. Junxian
Should the realm be governed as a centralized political entity, or would the population be better served by a system of decentralized, local rule?
What institutions would maximize the interests of the local population without undermining political cohesiveness and unity?
What is the most effective way to recruit men of talent and integrity into government service?
What system better guarantees frontier defense and the suppression of local insurrections?
Summary: Fengjian vs. Junxian
Arguments in Favor of Junxian System
Arguments in Favor of Fengjian System
Secures greater stability and control for the emperor and his dynasty.
Landholders treat their land and people as family; Supports the notion of loyalty and responsibility within familial and regional ties..
Promotes stability of the Chinese imperium as a whole.
Represents the idealized values of family (jia), emphasizing Confucian morals.
Centralization denies private or selfish interests, promoting the general interest (gong).
Emphasizes local governance and personal investment in land and community.
Fiscal Reform: From Equal Field System to Double Tax
Equal-field System
In 485, the Northern Wei implemented the equal-field system for land reform.
The equal-field system involved state-owned land divided into family-sized plots for peasants, who paid taxes and provided labor for imperial projects.
Each married couple received a land grant for their working lives, with the land remaining state property.
This system continued with modifications during the Qi, Zhou, and Tang dynasties.
The main goal of the equal-field system was to cultivate as much abandoned land as possible.
Double tax
In 780, a two-tax system was introduced, collecting taxes biannually in summer and autumn, replacing the previous equal-field system.
Each province was assigned a specific revenue quota.
Special commissioners were appointed by the court to raise revenues through various methods.
They experimented with selling offices, manipulating the money supply, and taxing trade.
Salt tax for the state: By 779, the salt monopoly generated half of the central government’s revenue.
New Geography of Empire
Before 755
Throughout its history, the Tang empire was centered in the capital Chang’an and the surrounding Guanzhong region.
Large families were forcibly resettled near Chang’an, and funds from across the empire were invested to enhance the economic productivity of the Guanzhong area.
After 755
Following the An Lushan rebellion, the Tang court lost control over much of the northeast.
A new geopolitical axis emerged from the northwest to the southeast: the fertile lower Yangzi region provided essential food and income for the court and the northwest.
A wealthy, demilitarized south that supported a strategically located northern capital, a pattern that influenced later imperial China.
A New World Born
After 755, the Tang dynasty experienced a decline in state control over property and subjects. But that also led to increased commercialization, urbanization, and new innovation.
Shift in Land Regulation:
The state abandoned its efforts to regulate land ownership following the An Lushan rebellion.
Urbanization:
As restrictions on trade in cities diminished, urban life evolved toward a model where commercial establishments blended with residences.
Growth of Market Towns:
New market towns emerged in the countryside to support a more commercialized agricultural system, led by brokers and tradesmen.
A New World Born, Continued
After 755, the Tang dynasty experienced a decline in state control over property and subjects. But that also led to increased commercialization, urbanization, and new innovation.
Elite Families and Examination System:
Elite families’ influence declined after the Tang’s fall, while the examination system continued in later dynasties.
Professional Military:
The family-based military system was largely replaced by professional soldiers.
Restructured Trade Relations:
Tang merchants adapted their trade with the outside world, maintaining ties with northern nomadic groups while increasing overseas trade from the fertile south, particularly with Korea, Japan, Southeast Asia, India, and the Persian Gulf, integrating China into a global maritime trade system.
Critical Essays
The classical prose essay (gu wen) is seen as a major intellectual achievement of the late Tang period and a high point in Chinese literature.
Tang essayists were influenced by two main ideas: a desire to return to ancient writing models and efforts to restore dynastic power after the An Lushan rebellion.
The Classics Movement
Increased trade and urban commercialization during the Tang dynasty led to the emergence of new literary genres.
Lyric poetry
The first half of the dynasty was the golden age of lyric verse
Famous poets: Wang Wei, Li Bo (Bai), and Du Fu.
Critical prose essay
Critical prose essay as a significant literary form.
Han Yu emphasized that good literature should be distinctive and personal, rejecting the idea of achieving true style through imitation.
He believed education should help individuals develop their own unique voices and original phrases.
Discussion: The Original Way
What does Han Yu mean by the Way and its Power?
What caused the decline of the way?
How do we get back to the original way?
Han Yu
Classical prose writers, particularly Han Yu (768–824), are recognized for elevating minor writing forms (essays, prefaces, letters, inscriptions) into major artistic genres.
Han Yu urged students to move away from standard poems and return to “classic” pre-imperial and Han writings, emphasizing their more flexible rhythms over rigid prose forms.
Students should focus on the ideas of ancient sages rather than their specific wording: they should engage with ancient texts to internalize their thoughts, allowing for spontaneous composition in a classical style.
Summary: The Original Way
“Antiquity” was not just a collection of ancient texts to escape modernity but a “spiritual state” achieved through self-cultivation.
Internalizing the wisdom of ancient texts required constant reading and personal transformation through disciplined writing.
“Study” refines one’s understanding of the Way, while “writing” perfects normative patterns.
Self-cultivation would remove contemporary decadence and embody the classical ideals of the sages.
Rule by Literary Elites
Literary men like Han Yu sought to recentralize power, emphasizing the emperor as the source of order, reliant on literary men for several reasons:
Clear communication between the ruler and the people was essential, requiring literary men to convey the emperor’s decisions and the people’s situations.
Literary education helped cultivate civil virtues and made literary men uniquely qualified to advise the emperor.
Literary texts showcased the writer’s character, making them valuable in examinations and bettering officials compared to eunuchs or fiscal experts.
Huang Chao: From Aspiring Scholar to Rebel Leader
Uprisings began in 874, leading to the collapse of the Tang dynasty.
The rebels lacked a clear ideology, primarily seeking to loot cities and evade taxes.
Huang Chao, a failed examination candidate, became the leader of the rebels.
In 880, he captured Chang’an and declared a new dynasty, but the rebels could not establish a stable regime.
The rebels abandoned the devastated city of Chang’an in 883, leaving the central government powerless.
The Beginning of the End
After 885, the emperor was taken prisoner by eunuchs and military governors.
In 904, Zhu Wen, a former rebel, captured the emperor and executed his entire entourage, except for the emperor.
Zhu Wen transferred his capital at Luoyang and killed the last Tang boy-emperor in 907.
He founded the Liang dynasty with dual capitals at Luoyang and Kaifeng, marking the end of Chang’an as an imperial capital.
From Tang to Five Dynasties
From 907 to 960, multiple regional kingdoms emerged in northern and southern China, each replaced by new regimes led by generals.
This period is known as the Five Dynasties, ending in 960 when Zhao Kuangyin founded the Song dynasty.
Reflecting on the Tang
Tang dynasty (618–907) as the peak of imperial China, both politically and culturally.
The Tang empire was the largest before the Manchu Qing dynasty and became the center of an East Asian world connected by religion, script, and institutions.
The first half of the Tang is celebrated for military conquests and exceptional poetry.
The second half of the Tang dynasty was marked by important changes following the An Lushan rebellion in 756.
Late Tang and the Creation of Later Imperial China
Recentralization amid devolution:
This period involved abandoning old institutions from the Han dynasty, including the equal-field land system and family-based military structures.
Elite families linked their status to the state through the examination system, which continued after the Tang’s collapse.
Commercialization and urbanization:
Loss of state control over property and subjects.
Urban life evolved into a model where commercial establishments mixed with residences, and new market towns emerged in the countryside.
A new cultural geography:
The Yangzi valley becoming the economic center after the An Lushan rebellion.
Competitive intra-state relations: Tang, Uyghur, Nanzhao, and Tibetan States.
“Sinosphere”: A multilingual but culturally interconnect East Asian region.
Tang merchants restructured trade relations, maintaining contact with nomadic groups and developing maritime trade with Southeast Asia, India, and the Persian Gulf.